Donate… Help fund the coverage that holds judges, insiders, and broken systems accountable.
Lately, every time we turn around, another DEI soft-on-crime judge is making another dangerous ruling. This latest one is so bad that people are now asking: whose side is the justice system actually on?
Clearly, it’s not the victim’s side.
Because when a teenage boy viciously attacks multiple girls, causes injuries so severe a doctor says one of them was seconds from death, and walks away with probation, something is seriously wrong.
READ MORE: Is Justice Jackson’s judicial buffoonery giving black women a bad name?
In Oklahoma, that massive failure now has a name: Jesse Butler.
Here he is. His father is a former big shot at the University of Oklahoma.
And the circumstances surrounding his sentence are raising alarms far beyond one courtroom. This is becoming a nationwide outrage, and for very good reason.
This case exploded after details emerged about what Butler was actually convicted of and what punishment he avoided.
According to reporting, Butler faced up to 78 years in prison for multiple sexual assaults involving two high school girls. One victim required surgery for injuries to her neck. Another described repeated rape and strangulation. As we mentioned earlier, medical professionals said one of the attacks came within seconds of killing the poor girl.
No jail time. That is the sentence for Jesse Butler, despite charges of multiple rapes, strangulation, and video evidence involving two victims. Prosecutors asked for 78 years, but a judge with links to Butler's family let him off with a slap on the wrist. pic.twitter.com/X4x8LkDVXe
— Ian Miles Cheong (@ianmiles) December 10, 2025
Despite all of that, the court granted Butler “youthful offender” status and sentenced him to probation.
Insanity.
NEW: Oklahoma teen confronted after avoiding all jail time despite being convicted of r*ping two high school students.
Jesse Butler was facing a 78-year sentence, but was granted youthful offender status.
The r*pist so badly assaulted one of the girls that she needed surgery on her neck. According to the girl, Butler repeatedly r*ped and strangled her.
The girl was about 30 seconds from losing her life, according to a doctor.
Butler was only placed on probation despite the horrific details, avoiding 78 years behind bars. His father is a former football director at Oklahoma State University.
Infuriating.
NEW: Oklahoma teen confronted after avoiding all jail time despite being convicted of r*ping two high school students.
Jesse Butler was facing a 78-year sentence, but was granted youthful offender status.
The r*pist so badly assaulted one of the girls that she needed surgery on… pic.twitter.com/JYrf2zecAz
— Collin Rugg (@CollinRugg) December 9, 2025
A violent offender walks free, while his victims live with the physical and psychological fallout and torture. And the explanation given is rehabilitation?
Okay, that flimsy argument might make sense for shoplifting or vandalism. It does not add up with near-fatal sexual violence. This kid behaves like the next Night Stalker or Hillside Strangler serial killer.
READ MORE: Stossel truth bomb: Many say slavery is a uniquely American crime. That’s a huge lie…
The public response was immediate and furious, especially when Butler appeared in court afterward as if nothing had happened. This chubby twerp waddled into court like he was annoyed to be there.
An ex high school baseball star who was convicted of violently raping two girls was confronted by protesters and booed as he arrived in court after it was confirmed he walks free with no prison.
Jesse Butler, 18, of Stillwater, previously pleaded no contest as a youthful offender to charges involving sexual assault, strangulation, and domestic abuse over the summer, with a judge allowing him to skip jail time, sparking public outrage.
The angry crowd returned to the Payne County courthouse on Monday flashing signs that read, “No Jail, No Justice,” as they demanded accountability for Butler, who comes from a prominent family.
“Why did you rape those girls, Jesse?” one irate protester demanded as the teenage attacker walked through a medal detector.
“Do you have anything to say to the victims?”
“The criminal is innocent, basically, and the the victims are the ones having to serve the time,” protester Tori Grey told local News9.
Video from inside the courthouse also showed the nonchalant teen entering the courtroom in a black suit as he walked through the metal detectors for his hearing.
And the body-camera footage makes something else painfully clear. Butler’s mother treats him like a fragile child, not a near-grown adult who carried out brutal, life-altering violence.
So you rape, sodomize, use instruments while raping, and strangle a girl leaving her near death and you are out and about?
How? It’s called a deal and the DA made quite a deal with this devil named Jesse Butler.
Everything was pled down to virtually nothing. Butler was charged as child, not an adult. Butler is no child.
Butler pled Nolo. No time behind bars and as long as he keeps his nose clean, his record will be expunged.
Butler’s initial charges included “two attempted rapes, three charges of rape by instrumentation, one count of sexual battery, one count of forcible oral sodomy, two counts of domestic assault and battery by strangulation and one count of domestic assault and battery.”
The deal this DA struck is reprehensible.
He is a monster, and he will strike again. The DA and judge should be held responsible.
Who will be his next victim?
And the LEOs in this treating him with kid gloves.
Unbelievable. Again, what about the victims?
Predators don’t change. They just get older.
So you rape, sodomize, use instruments while raping, and strangle a girl leaving her near death and you are out and about?
How? It’s called a deal and the DA made quite a deal with this devil named Jesse Butler.
Everything was pled down to virtually nothing. Butler was charged… pic.twitter.com/dBytJ9dcjq
— Jennifer Coffindaffer (@CoffindafferFBI) November 3, 2025
All of this brings us back, full circle, to the judge overseeing this case. The official explanation offered by the court focuses on compliance, procedure, and rehabilitation plans. But sane people argue those explanations ignore the horror of the crimes and the optics surrounding who benefited from mercy… it certainly wasn’t the two victims who are shattered for life.
A Payne County judge has allowed an 18-year-old Stillwater resident convicted of sexual assault, strangulation and domestic abuse involving two high school students to continue serving a probation sentence under Oklahoma’s youthful offender law.
The defendant, Jesse Mack Butler, pleaded no contest earlier this year to multiple felony charges stemming from incidents that occurred when he was 16 and 17.
His case returned to court during a scheduled review hearing in Stillwater, where a district judge determined he remained compliant with the strict rehabilitation plan imposed during sentencing. Demonstrators again gathered outside the courthouse as the ruling was announced.
The outcome has renewed public scrutiny of how Oklahoma courts apply the youthful offender statute in cases involving serious violence. Advocates have raised questions about transparency, victim notification and the perception of conflicts of interest, particularly because Judge Susan Worthington, the special judge who granted youthful offender status in July, previously earned two degrees from Oklahoma State University, where the defendant’s father once worked in athletics administration.
The case also interacts with Oklahoma’s constitutional victims’ rights amendment, which requires reasonable efforts to keep victims informed of major developments.
Court filings and police reports lay out exactly what prosecutors were dealing with and how serious the charges actually were before this DEI soft-on-crime judge stepped in and changed everything. Rumors are flying that this judge has a close relationship with the teen’s powerful father, although nothing is confirmed.
The Lawyer Monthly piece goes on:
Police affidavits detail repeated assaults, forced sexual acts and a strangulation incident that one victim said rendered her unconscious. Investigators later reported finding video on Butler’s phone that aligned with one of the reported attacks. Both relationships were described as dating relationships that had become coercive and violent.
Prosecutors charged Butler in adult court with multiple felonies, including sexual assault–related offenses, domestic abuse and strangulation. At the time charges were filed, the potential adult sentence could have resulted in many years of imprisonment. In July 2025, however, Special Judge Susan Worthington reclassified the case under Oklahoma’s Youthful Offender Act, a law created in the late 1990s to handle serious juvenile cases through a blended system focused on treatment, oversight and a suspended adult sentence.
That change paved the way for the August 25 sentencing, which placed Butler on supervised probation rather than in state custody. The terms include mandatory weekly counseling, sex-offender–specific treatment, regular reporting to a probation officer and additional behavioural restrictions enforced through the court until he turns 19.
The questions surrounding this insane case practically write themselves.
Why was a youthful offender status applied to crimes this severe? Is there more to the rumors about the judge and the teen’s father? And why were the victims reportedly left in the dark as all these big decisions were being made?
Let’s play Devil’s advocate and say everything that went down is totally and technically legal… it makes no difference, because the appearance alone is so incredibly damaging, especially in this day and age, when it feels as if criminals are the new “victims.”
We have a justice system that loves to talk about compassion but doesn’t show a lot to the victims. Time and time again, we’re seeing our US courts send the message that extreme violence can somehow be managed, excused, or “supervised” away. This gives these soft-on-crime judges and prosecutors the ability to protect perpetrators and endanger the rest of us.
READ MORE: Why do so many female homemakers cheat? The answer is surprisingly simple…
The girls in this case deserved so much more.
Instead, they got a lousy probation ruling, while they’ll spend a life sentence dealing with the aftermath of this violent crime. Every American watching this unfold should be furious, and that judge should be investigated.
Donate… Help fund the coverage that holds judges, insiders, and broken systems accountable.
NEWSFEED — FOLLOW ON X — GAB — GETTR — TRUTH SOCIAL — BLUESKY
Join the Discussion