Discussion about this post

User's avatar
CaliforniaLost's avatar

Future Harvard Presidents have to start somewhere...

Expand full comment
A. Klarke Heinecke's avatar

This reminds me of a student I had in Precalc (dark time in life, reduced to HS teaching, albeit outstanding district, for a while, wondering how my life had gone so wrong - long story I would not share with NYT reporter but everyone would know some of the names involved).

Anyway, this child's father (single parent) was insanely set on him being a genius, a prodigy, and pushed him to take Precalc as a 6th grader. The kid had the performance down. He would confidently draw out diagrams and spout physics formulas, act like a "genius." The problem was that my B.S. was in physics and he did not know what he was talking about, was just aping vocabulary. I complained to admin that he should under no circumstances be admitted to Precalc but I was overridden.

He could not understand the material; no one wanted to work with him because he brought their scores down (Common Core forced group work and teacher evaluations depended on it, insane). The child had a nervous breakdown at age 11 and had to leave school.

Now I wonder if I should have reported the father to CPS, yet the government seems like such a dystopian last case option. That poor kid is going to have to find his way. (My own mom was schizophrenic. We found our way.)

Expand full comment
95 more comments...