🧵Jefferson Davis’ thousand-page "The Rise and Fall of The Confederate Government" is one people are always shocked to learn exists.
I’ve known Civil War history buffs to spit-take “Wait What!?” it is so rarely cited or talked about.
Every Westerner grows up learning Mein Kampf is this evil book you shouldn’t read and is, we are told, very very poorly written (by people who read YA and NYT AutoBio Fiction no less)… They also grow up being taught the confederacy was an evil regime nearly as bad as Hitler’s…
But it seems we’re carefully directed to the Mad Austrian Painter’s book and NOT directed to the book written by the US regime’s ancient internal enemy, written natively in English, and argued not with obscure pre-war European geopolitical norms, economics, and ethnography, but instead presents a highly plausible reading of America’s own founding documents, history, and values as presented by one of the most celebrated politicians and statesmen of his day.
Out of all the politicians, warriors, and madmen who’ve taken on the US government, this is the man who came closest to taking Washington DC, driving the American President himself to flight, and ending the United States permanently… And he lived to write about it!
And Americans don’t even know he wrote a thing!
And I went to his house! The White House of the Confederacy in Richmond, Virginia, now buried amidst bad neighborhoods, hospitals, and open-air drug dealing (it is something to walk through what 6 generations of Southerners warned of)… I paid the 15$ to take the tour, and in the midst of all that, I saw the Jefferson Davis house remarkably and beautifully preserved and restored (The Daughters of the Confederacy made a big project of it in the 1890s)… At the end of that tour when I went to the museum gift shop in the neighboring hospital, the tour guide carefully locking and closing the shutters behind up…
The extensive Museum gift store did not sell Davis’ books! Lots of works by or on Frederick Douglass and various books on the supposed Enigma of Lincoln…
But NOT the books by the man whose house IS the Museum.
THAT IS CANCELLED! When you go to the author’s house and you can’t buy his book!
What a Mad Lad.
Image on the right is The White House of the Confederacy. I asked, it wasn’t Losing the War that did this, it was still a ritzy neighborhood til the 1960s… This was just the only white household that was not put to flight.)
The above is an Excerpt from my "Real Banned Books list"
For any of you who doubt the work has been effectively disappeared... Especially when you consider this was THE HEAD OF STATE for one of the two belligerents (and Lincoln didn't live to write a book)
Tolkien is capeshit wearing the skinsuit of the Anglo-Saxon tradition.
Contrast Beowulf, Le Morte De Arthur, the Germanic Eddas, the Odyssey, The Aeneid... And you can see none of the structure or values or the stories are at all comparable. Tolkien never wrote a single revenge cycle.
But rather his values and stories resemble nothing so much as Modern Marvel movies.
A sexless world of Eternal Children and equally sexless bearded men, with no meaningful desires except for trinkets and Macguffins meant to show their virtues are sins and they should have had no desires at all... and villains who when not faceless beasts and disposable vermin, have committed the crime of... Wanting something.
Not a single one of his heroes has a rivalry or hatred of any of his villains, and certainly nothing familial, personal, or romantic such as is the case of every classical and anglo-saxon story.
One wonders why Gandalf went to Bilbo at all... So Bilbo could find a wife? Found a new hobbit Kingdom with his fortune? Avert some terrible destiny? Slay an enemy or rival?
No! So he could just come home and do nothing for another 50+ years.
For all the shit GRRM rightly gets for Game of Thrones devolving into feminist/social justice anti-narrative and plodding hopeless misery (Name any children BORN during A Song of Ice and Fire and the war of 5 kings who live? Indeed it contradicts his own worldbuilding, since half the cast was born or married and formed families as a direct result of the earlier Robert's rebellion)... inspite of all that Game of Thrones is far CLOSER to traditional western storytelling and values, with named characters with families and hopes and dreams, and lusts and rivalries and children and revenge cycles on all sides.
By contrast Tolkien, very uniquely even by the standards of the 40s and 50s, creates a sexless world where pretty much no one has families, romances, lusts, hopes, desires, etc. Save some abstract desire to "Save the world" or "defeat evil"
Name a single Tolkien Character who has a significant Relationship with their father, mother, or wife?
The only exception is Denathor... Ie. A Mad King to be overcome. Arwen doesn't even appear in the main text of the books
But what about...
Are you going to reference something published by JRR Tolkien? Or Christopher Tolkien?
I agree Christopher Tolkien was vastly more in touch with the Western Tradition than his father.
Hanania makes Casey Affleck at the start of "Assassination of Jesse James" seem normal and well adjusted
There is something deeply wrong with any figure who decide to interact with him and pretend the most unsettling thing ever seen isn't happening right in front of them
Every inflection is wrong, every muscle spasm, every lip movement, every reaction, every part of his face that's unusually plump, smooth, and youthful, or that's strangely aged, worn, & thin
Every part of him is disingenuous, faking something human or concealing something alien
he's 39... Yet not a single trait of him is 39... He combines the most bizzare traits of an autistic 10 year old and 90 year old jewish woman... As much an age that has never existed before as Madonna post-plastic surgery.
Young white men are so damned close to terror and ethnic cleansing it is unreal.
Having every rule rigged against them, their every institution betray them, and then called losers by the people their tax dollars subsidize and the boomers their childhood suffering gave peace to
That a full moratorium on all immigration for 15 years and complete repeal of the 1964 civil right isn't the opening bid, is a the sign we're headed to hot civil war.
An entire generation of boys sees Hitler as the only figure in history who didn't want them enslaved and killed
I will ask @ThomasEWoods and @BobMurphyEcon who for some reason are defending Elon and Vivek.
Why do you want you children enslaved, immiserated, disenfranchised in their homeland, reduced to a minority, and inevitably killed by ethnic enemies?